Pros: SUPER value, especially as compared with rates on St. John. Renting on St. Thomas and paying the $50 round trip on the ferry is DEFINITELY the way to go.
I rented at the office in Charlotte Amalie, which is located outside of the airport, and the cost was a lot lower. Despite what the website said, they allowed me to return it to the airport for no extra cost.
Staff was extremely friendly and helpful.
Cons: St. John's roads are insanely steep and curvy. Transmission was not in great shape, and the car really strained, sometimes coming to near stops on steep inclines, even in low gear. Given my experience, I'd opt for a Jeep type next time.
6 Jan 2016
Cons: When we arrived at the airport, A bit apprehensive having never been anywhere that requires driving on the left side, our 4 door Jeep was not available. The clerk did not seem too concerned with this. She was checking her watch the entire time as if we were keeping her from something else much more important. She gave us a beat up Toyota Camry. No SUV's available. I am 6'6" tall which made it a tight, uncomfortable, fit. It was dirty & smelly. I mean REALLY smelly. We had to postpone our plans for our day in order to wait around for the car to be swapped "IF", as she put it, a Jeep becomes available. Not a great start to a vacation.
28 Jan 2016
Pros: The agent was very helpful
the price was affordable
2 Feb 2016
Budget in St Thomas
Pros: The location was actually in town, and not at the airport, This suited us much better as we were staying on a boat in a marine nearby.
14 Feb 2016
Didn't have car we reserved!
Cons: They didn't have the car we reserved. It forced us to upgrade to a more expensive vehicle and pay more than we planned. If we wanted the car we reserved we would have had to sit and wait for one to be returned and cleaned before they could give it to us. This is not acceptable.
23 Feb 2016
Pros: We found two roaches in the car. Tires in the car were worn out as well.
6 Mar 2016
Good car but pickup a hassle.
Pros: New car, Toyota Yaris, handled well on mountainous roads of St. Thomas. Good on gas.
Cons: The car I booked at STT (ST. Thomas USVI airport) with Budget actually turned out to be an off-site nearby and NO shuttle to get there. Had to pay $15 for a short cab ride AS THERE IS NO COURTESY SHUTTLE. Advertised rate for airport was misleading. A true airport Budget vehicle was charging $60 more than our Budget booked rate for STT ON KAYAK.
4 Aug 2016
Car described on website not available
Cons: Car described was not available and kayak price was not honered.
6 Dec 2016
Pros: Although I arrived over two hours past my pickup time, they still rented me a car.
When I dropped off the car, they gave me a ride to the departure, check-in area.
Cons: The line to get the car took 1.5 hrs and then they charged me $12 more than the cost quoted on the kayak site (not including insurance). The walk to my rental car was a little long and included steps, which was a bit difficult for a woman with heavy bags.
7 Oct 2016
Great car, nice vacation, pick-up and drop off inc
Pros: low mileage car, a Honda Sonata, and it was very clean.
Cons: A bit of a difficult walk from the lot where cars are returned, having to schlepp your luggage down the stairs to a street, then across to the airport entry. Especially for we over-60-somethings, closer and no stairs would be a big help.
Pros: Staff were friendly and helpful! Would rent from the again
Cons: Will rent from them again, great service !
23 Nov 2015
Pros: Schedules change, sometimes on short notice. The manager waived the 24-hour extension charge of $100. Outstanding.
Cons: The roads are rough there, the cars have lots of dents and dings and scraped fenders from the speed bumps (actually, they are small mountains) and potholes (actually they are small lakes). The additional fees imposed at St. Thomas are pretty high and not reflected in the price you see online.
28 Nov 2015
Pros: Always friendly service
Cons: My car lock clicker didn't work - annoying
9 Dec 2015
Pros: REASONABLY PRICED & ALLOWED TO TAKE CAR TO ST JOHN
Cons: There was only one reservation agent and she was doing lots of multitasking and did not provide the best directions. When I returned the vehicle, she was still there and carried on a long phone conversation and failed to properly check me in... I r'cd no receipt.
3 Jan 2016
Pros: The Dodge van was very GOOD just what we needed. Clean vehicle. The location very close to airport and shuttle service to departures was good. Staff were professional. For busy period between Christmas & New years it was good experience, Suggestions in the negative list
Cons: They close at 6:00 pm . Not in airport arrival area like other major brands. American Air flight arrived after midnight. Had to take taxi to hotel which was = 1 day rental. Called from Philly airport to notify $rental of late arrival but van stilled needed; the staff stated over committed on van rental & come next afternoon/ not morning. $ rental insisted filling with premium fuel. A/C needed to be charged as the a/c system operated not as cold as it should be. slight issue.
11 Jan 2016
Not as bad as we thought
Pros: We rented a 4 door Jeep. It was in fantastic condition (only 600 miles on it). The Jeep did well over the week - we even brought it over to St John on the car ferry and no problems. Drop off was great - very easy and quick.
My sister also rented a "new" Jeep from them but the tire was low when they got it. Dollar assured them, it just needed air once and would otherwise be fine. They spent every other day getting air in that same tire. Luckily nothing major happened, but it was a total nuisance to have to get air 6 times in 10 days.
Cons: Slow service picking up the car. They try to upsell you consistently by threatening that if anything happens to the car you will be charged for all the days it is out of commission, the $250 cleaning fee for excess sand, etc.
They are offsite so you have to take a shuttle to the location. Not s huge deal unless like us you are lugging lots of bags and kids.
Prices are pretty standard in St Thomas and St John.
31 Jan 2016
Pros: Return was EASYand without problems
Cons: Car, especially outside was dirty.. Windshield was filthy and had no washer fluid. Otherwise OK
2 Oct 2016
Pros: The drop off was uneventful
Cons: The pick up was exhausting. The counter lady at pick up was ride. The car was beat up really bad and the interior was cloth was dirty. When I reserved the car I was offered the rental insurance and paid for it and was told I would only need to pay the balance for the rental. Upon arrival we were informed that insurance was not valid and we had to purchase their insurance an additional $200 for it. The attitude alone of the desk person alone would make me not use them again.
4 Oct 2016
Don't EVER rent from here.
Pros: There was honestly nothing to like. From the rude staff, to being lied to about wait times, the entire experience was horrible.
Cons: I only rented from Dollar because it was a few dollars cheaper than the others. The Dollar office in St. Croix is not at the airport itself but is very close, and they offer a shuttle, so I figured no big deal. Boy was I wrong! I called and asked for the shuttle, at which time I was told I shuttle would arrive in "10-12 minutes". Sounded reasonable enough, so I waited. Long story short, after communicating with them three more times and more lies about wait times, the shuttle arrived after about an hour of waiting. I get to the office and explain that waiting for an hour for the shuttle was unacceptable after being told my wait would only be 10 minutes, and that I would like a discount for an upgrade for my time being wasted. She got a sincere attitude with me, and told me that "waiting was part of the process", and that "there would be no discount" or any sort of compensation for being this honest to me and causing me to wait for an hour. This conversation went on for about 15 minutes, with her continuing to provide terrible customer service. Since my time was so undervalued, I ended up canceling my reservation, which I need to double check on. Please do yourself a favor and never rent from Dollar or Thrifty on St. Croix.
7 Nov 2016
Pick up and drop off left a lot to be desired
Pros: Toyota Corolla was a good value and had low miles.
Cons: after Arrival at St Thomas airport it took 40 minutes for pick up.
On the return, we waited 30 minutes in a bus with broken air conditioning.
The driver made sure his fan was on so he could be cooler
Cons: Pick up in the morning is horrible. I had to wait 40 minutes for the shuttle. When I was renting I heard another customer saying he waited 45 min for the shuttle.
Another thing is that they never have your car ready. Yo always have to wait for the car to be cleaned.
3 Dec 2015
Pros: Thrifty has better rates than others at St Thomas. Offers the same range of cars as others. Shuttle from the rental to the airport was fast and easy.
Cons: The pickup from the airport was unmarked and confusing. The car pick up gets busy when several flights arrive around the same time. The car itself is clean but pretty dinged up. Overall an ok experience.
3 Dec 2015
Cons: Thrifty was out of vans and had to send me to a local company that was a junk van. Van very unsafe to drive and had very bald tires. They were worn all the way down to warning gap on them. Not good to drive on with the wet roads on the very steep hills.
5 Jan 2016
Pros: SERVICE IN TRANSPORTATION BETWEEN RENTAL LOCATION AND AIRPORT
Cons: CAR WAS VISIBLY BANGED UP ON ALL FOUR SIDES. THE FRONT CAR SHELL WAS LOOSE FROM THE MAIN STRUCTURE OF THE CAR. ALL THIS WAS NOTED BY US ON THE RENTAL FORM, BUT UPON RETURNING THE CAR, I CAME UNDER PRESSURE THAT ALL THIS WAS DAMAGE CAUSED BY ME.
I ALSO DID NOT LIKE THE "LOSS OF USE" CLAUSE IN THE RENTAL CONTRACT IN THAT IT IS AN OPEN INVITATION FOR CORRUPTING THE RENTAL SYSTEM
5 Nov 2016
Pros: This was an older vehicle that was not well maintained.
8 Nov 2016
Vehicle not available
Cons: When you request a full size car and are confirmed then arrive and find out one isn't available but you are already at the offsite location why confirm the car
29 Nov 2016
Pros: Minivan was in good shape. Service was decent but they act like they are doing you a favour by renting to you.
Cons: Check in process takes forever as they have 1 person working at all times. They push you for insurance by saying that you have to keep paying while the car is being repaired - don't even know if that's legal.
30 Nov 2016
what you should know
Pros: Car Was in very good condition
Cons: Rental yard was small and overcrowded. Returning the car was difficult because you could even park the car in the gates. Had to stop on the street for over 15 minutes. When i got inside i need a taxi and the attendant couldn't even call one for me. Didn't even attempt to look. Great service! huh. I had a call and cancel my Allianz Car Rental insurance because they don't accept as a recognized insurance. So please don't get this when you book your car.
Cons: Selection of cars was not accurately listed on kayak. For ex. We requested a mustang and got a VW. We loved the VW anyways, but other Kayak customers may want to know ahead of time. That's the only negative thing I could think of.
19 Oct 2016
Excellent customer service and positive "can do" a
Pros: I had an early flight on the 18th and they met me 1.5 hours earlier
(06:30) prior to opening (0800) in order to accommodate my schedule.
They unsolicited a call to me to coordinate an early meeting to turn the car in and give me a ride to the Airport. Excellent customer service !
24 Oct 2016
Pros: Fast and courteous service
Cons: There was nothing to dislike
4 Dec 2016
Pros: Great, fast service with a very helpful staff and a free car model upgrade.
Cons: The location is not at the airport, but the had a shuttle.