$180 Find Cheap Flights from New York to Toronto Island – Compare and Save

Among airlines operating New York to Toronto Island Airport flights:

• Porter Airlines: offers free seat selection
• Air Canada: offers extra legroom; offers free seat selection
• Air Transat: offers extra legroom; offers free seat selection
• United Airlines: offers free seat selection

Extra legroom and free seat selection availability depends on fare class and route.

2 airlines operate flights between New York and Toronto Island Airport. The airlines offering direct flights on this route include:

• Porter Airlines
• Air Canada

Flights from New York to Toronto Island Airport may depart from several airports in New York area, including Newark (EWR), New York John F Kennedy Intl (JFK) and New York LaGuardia (LGA). Flights usually arrive at Toronto Island (YTZ).

Here are some options for this route, based on selected ticket types and cabin classes:

• Porter Airlines: a cabin bag and a checked bag in Economy class
• Air Canada: a cabin bag and a checked bag in Economy class
• Air Transat: a cabin bag and a checked bag in Economy class

Bag allowance can vary by ticket type, cabin class, route, and airline, so travellers should check the fare details before booking.

Only Economy class is available on flights from New York to Toronto Island Airport.

On this route, stopover flights are cheaper than direct options on average. Stopover fares average $388 return via Ottawa (YOW), compared with $430 for direct.

There is no standard. Checked bag policies vary by airline on this route. Most carriers charge $30–$141 for the first checked bag in Economy. Premium fares and elite status bookings typically include a free checked bag.

One-stop flights from New York to Toronto Island Airport most commonly connect through:

• Ottawa (YOW) – 65% of one-stop connections
• Montreal Pierre Elliott Trudeau Intl (YUL) – 32% of one-stop connections
• Boston Logan Intl (BOS) – 3% of one-stop connections

Ottawa (YOW) handles the largest share of one-stop connections on this route.

Yes. Being flexible with your travel dates can save you up to 16% on the New York to Toronto Island Airport route. Friday is the cheapest departure day at $416 return on average, while Sunday is the most expensive at $491, a difference of $75. KAYAK's flexible dates feature shows options up to 3 days before and after your selected dates, making it easier to compare nearby fares.

A flight is considered delayed when it departs 15 minutes or more after its scheduled time. This is the standard used by the US Department of Transportation and most airline industry reporting. On the New York to Toronto Island Airport route, 30% of flights were delayed in the past 3 months, with delays averaging 2 hours 8 minutes.

Morning is the busiest departure period on New York to Toronto Island Airport flights, with 50% leaving in that window. Afternoon departures account for 30%, Evening flights for 20%, and Night flights for 0%.

Some of the most popular sights in Toronto Island Airport are Sankofa Square, Union Station, and YYZ Artists' Outlet. These are among the most viewed places in Toronto Island Airport on KAYAK.

These are the earliest and latest flight times available from New York to Toronto Island Airport:

• Earliest: departs at 06:25 and lands at 08:05
• Latest: departs at 19:25 and lands at 21:05.

The flight takes about 1h 40m.

Last-minute fares on this route (booked within 2 weeks of departure) run 23% above the route average of $430. Book 6 weeks before departure for the lowest fares.

A direct flight from New York to Toronto Island Airport takes 1h 40m, covering 882 km.

Yes, a valid passport is required for this international route. Many destinations require at least six months of validity beyond your travel dates. Check your passport expiry well before booking.

Yes. Based on fares seen in the past 5 days, return flight prices on this route showed a wide range, from about $364 to $1,258. That means the highest observed fare was about 3x higher than the lowest one.

One-way fares from New York to Toronto Island Airport are currently lower than usual. Average one-way flight prices are about $189, which is 24% below the typical average for this route.

Air Canada is the only airline operating New York to Toronto Island Airport flights. 70% of its flights are on time.

Morning flights have the fewest delays on this route. Delays tend to pile up throughout the day as one late flight pushes the next, so earlier departures are usually more reliable.

Flying via Ottawa (YOW) gives the shortest average 1-stop total travel time of 4h 34m, compared to 5h 26m via Boston Logan Intl (BOS) and 5h 41m via Montreal Pierre Elliott Trudeau Intl (YUL).

Toronto Island Airport (YTZ) hosts 5 major car hire companies, with daily rates starting from around $18 for economy cars. Top options include:
• Hertz
• Enterprise Rent-A-Car
• National
• Advance Car And Truck Rental
• Budget

Return flights from New York to Toronto Island Airport range from $340 to $515, with an average of $430 over the past 12 months. Anything below $340 counts as a good deal.