Guest reviews
Overall rating
7.1
Good
Based on 3,149 reviews
Overall
6.7
Cleanliness
7.2
Comfort
7.2
Pickup/dropoff
6.4
Value for money
6.7
Skip to main content
Thrifty car rental prices in New York
| Compact | $118/day |
| Luxury | $53/day |
Pros
"Great car, nice and clean!."
(in 106 reviews)
"staff very friendly and helpful."
(in 114 reviews)
"Car was clean and decent."
(in 349 reviews)
Cons
"Bad customer service and rude"
(in 109 reviews)
"Everywhere else no cars available."
(in 101 reviews)
"Overcharged my credit card upon return."
(in 49 reviews)
Recent reviews
- All reviews
- Positive
- Neutral
- Negative
Find reviews that mention:
customer service
pick up the car
credit card
car was clean
nice car
great car
car available
compact car
great price
return the car
friendly staff
great experience
-
10.0
Pros: The staff was helpful, welcoming, and attentive, despite being busy with the small crowd of customers waiting to pick up cars for the weekend. They made sure I was given a car in the class I'd booked, supplied a vehicle in excellent condition, and explained how to find the car return entrance (which isn't clearly marked), When I brought the car back at the end of the rental, the staff member patiently answered my questions about a possible problem with a bridge toll and made helpful suggestions about how to avoid long waits when renting in the future.
review from
-
10.0
Quick and easy
Pros: It was fast and easy service. Brent was great too
review from
-
10.0
Cons: Nothing
review from
-
10.0
Good service
Pros: The car was clean. Was provided a low mileage vehicle that was very dependable. The car was upgraded at a discounted fee as well.
Cons: Location of the pickup
review from
-
10.0
Easy Return!
Pros: Nice people, no lines, and I didn't have to go through LGA to get there.
review from
-
2.0
Cons: Horrific experience. Two people working with around 60 people in line. Line didn’t move for hours. Had to take Lyft to Hertz to get a different car.
review from
-
8.0
Pros: Friendly and efficient staff
Cons: Heater vent didn't work
review from
-
8.0
Pros: The staff at both the pick up and the return were very friendly and helpful.
Cons: The car smelled a little like smoke with a lot of air freshener
review from
-
10.0
Going the extra mile…
Pros: The employees were responsive and helpful when I contacted them and when I was in the offices. The car was clean and ready to go when I arrived. I feel like I got the best service at the best price.
review from
-
8.4
Fast, easy, clean, and friendly
Pros: Fast, and easy service with a clean car. Everyone was friendly and helpful. Locals helped with directions and toll roads. I was impressed that there was almost no wait at the counter. Car was reliable, in good condition, clean, and ready immediately. They even made it easy to pick up at LGA and drop off at JFK. Would rent again.
review from
-
6.0
Cons: The staff at this Thrifty location were less than satisfactory while checking in. Their deameanor felt like they had zero cares and seemed pushy to add extras on to the rental. They were not good at communicating. If given a choice, I would not use this Thrifty location in the future.
review from
-
9.6
Quick and Easy
Pros: Fast, friendly service.
Cons: Took a little while for the receipt to print, but not a big deal. Rhe attendant was more concerned than me because he had other customers waiting.
review from
-
10.0
Pros: The staff was helpful, welcoming, and attentive, despite being busy with the small crowd of customers waiting to pick up cars for the weekend. They made sure I was given a car in the class I'd booked, supplied a vehicle in excellent condition, and explained how to find the car return entrance (which isn't clearly marked), When I brought the car back at the end of the rental, the staff member patiently answered my questions about a possible problem with a bridge toll and made helpful suggestions about how to avoid long waits when renting in the future.
review from
-
10.0
Quick and easy
Pros: It was fast and easy service. Brent was great too
review from
-
10.0
Cons: Nothing
review from
-
10.0
Good service
Pros: The car was clean. Was provided a low mileage vehicle that was very dependable. The car was upgraded at a discounted fee as well.
Cons: Location of the pickup
review from
-
10.0
Easy Return!
Pros: Nice people, no lines, and I didn't have to go through LGA to get there.
review from
-
10.0
Going the extra mile…
Pros: The employees were responsive and helpful when I contacted them and when I was in the offices. The car was clean and ready to go when I arrived. I feel like I got the best service at the best price.
review from
-
9.6
Quick and Easy
Pros: Fast, friendly service.
Cons: Took a little while for the receipt to print, but not a big deal. Rhe attendant was more concerned than me because he had other customers waiting.
review from
-
8.0
Pros: Friendly and efficient staff
Cons: Heater vent didn't work
review from
-
8.0
Pros: The staff at both the pick up and the return were very friendly and helpful.
Cons: The car smelled a little like smoke with a lot of air freshener
review from
-
8.4
Fast, easy, clean, and friendly
Pros: Fast, and easy service with a clean car. Everyone was friendly and helpful. Locals helped with directions and toll roads. I was impressed that there was almost no wait at the counter. Car was reliable, in good condition, clean, and ready immediately. They even made it easy to pick up at LGA and drop off at JFK. Would rent again.
review from
-
2.0
Cons: Horrific experience. Two people working with around 60 people in line. Line didn’t move for hours. Had to take Lyft to Hertz to get a different car.
review from
-
6.0
Cons: The staff at this Thrifty location were less than satisfactory while checking in. Their deameanor felt like they had zero cares and seemed pushy to add extras on to the rental. They were not good at communicating. If given a choice, I would not use this Thrifty location in the future.
review from
Other suppliers in New York scored
- 7.7/10 Avis car hires in New York
- 6.7/10 Payless car hires in New York
- 6.8/10 Budget car hires in New York
- 7.6/10 Hertz car hires in New York
- 4.9/10 Advantage car hires in New York
- 8.6/10 Alamo car hires in New York
- 8.8/10 Enterprise car hires in New York
- 6.6/10 Dollar car hires in New York
- 6.2/10 Economy Rent a Car car hires in New York
Where can I find Thrifty hire cars in New York?
312 Federal Circle, Thrifty car hire
Address
312 Federal CirclePhone
+1 877 283 0898Top tips for hiring a car from Thrifty in New York
- 25% of our users found a car hire from Thrifty in New York for $34 or less
- Book your car hire from New York in Thrifty at least 9 weeks before your trip in order to get a below-average price
FAQs about hiring a car from Thrifty in New York
How much does it cost to hire a car from Thrifty in New York?
On average a car hire from Thrifty in New York costs $71 per day.
What is the most popular car hire from Thrifty in New York?
Economy (Chevrolet Spark or similar) is the most frequently booked car hire type from Thrifty in New York.
How many car hire locations does Thrifty have in New York?
Thrifty has 3 car hire locations in New York. Take a look at our Thrifty hire location map to find the best car hires near you.
Does Thrifty have a car hire location at the airport: John F Kennedy Intl Airport (JFK)?
Yes
Does Thrifty offer shuttle or airport pick-up services from John F Kennedy Intl Airport (JFK)?
Yes
Does Thrifty have a car hire location at the airport: Newark Airport (EWR)?
No (according to our data)
Does Thrifty offer shuttle or airport pick-up services from Newark Airport (EWR)?
Yes
Does Thrifty have a car hire location at the airport: LaGuardia Airport (LGA)?
Yes
Does Thrifty offer shuttle or airport pick-up services from LaGuardia Airport (LGA)?
Yes
